Debate is not enshrined in the Nigerian constitution or the electoral law in Nigeria. Even in the US where we adopted key aspects of our presidential democracy, debate is not sanctioned by law. However, since 1960, televised presidential debates have become a major staple of the electoral process in the US. It has been a veritable avenue for both party members and the unaffiliated undecided voters to cut through the clutter of campaign noise in order to choose their preferred candidates based on substance. In Nigeria, we are still grappling with the apparent lack of debates, especially presidential debates between flag bearers of political parties; whereas in the US, there are series of debates within the political parties even before the primary elections. Not only that, the same applies to other elective positions, including Senatorial, and Congressional seats, and the position of Governors and Mayors. Debates also create avenues for candidates to do battle based on  their authenticity, the veracity of their individual policies; and their position in key national issues.

The importance of debates in the current electoral cycle was amplified by the Chief Executive Officer of the Nigerian Economic Summit Group (NESG) when he stated recently in Abuja, that they are essential to the election process and are increasingly regarded as a tradition and the bedrock of a healthy democracy. According to him, debates “embody fundamental principles which ensure that the citizens are informed and actively involved in leadership choices and decision-making. At this critical time in our country’s history, it is now more important than ever to nudge Nigerians towards informed voting choices that result in transformational leaders with the knowledge and understanding of the issues that will steer our country toward shared economic prosperity.” The lack of debates, since the advent of the current political era, has compelled the electorate in most cases to caste their votes blind for the full spectrum of elective positions. In fact, the amount of money spent since 1999 to maintain both houses of the national assembly is not commensurate to their legislative output, in terms of volume of bills passed, or the level at which they have been able to fulfil their oversight functions on MDAs to ensure that they are not operating as independent silos without accountability.

Due to the lack of debates, the electorate has voted stark illiterates as legislators, thereby denying constituencies and senatorial districts the required robust debate on the floor before certain bills are passed. As a consequence, the country has been plagued by a rubber stamp legislative arm like the current 9th Assembly, and various state Houses of Assembly. Recently, the anticipation of most Nigerians to listen, and to interrogate the presidential candidates of the frontline political parties was rewarded with partial disappointment when the Presidential Candidates of the All Progressives Congress (APC), Bola Armed Tinubu and his Peoples Democratic Party (PDP) counterpart, former Vice President, Atiku Abubakar did not show up at the Townhall Series. The debate was organised by the Nigeria Electoral Debate Group (NEDG), Nigeria Economic Summit Group, Centre for Democracy and Development, and others.

Nigerians anticipated a robust debate among major contenders for the highest office in the land, but only Peter Obi of Labour Party, and Rabiu Kwankwaso, of the New Nigeria’s People Party made themselves available for the debate; even though the Presidential Candidate of PDP sent his running mate and Governor of Delta State, Ifeanyi Okowa in his stead. That robust debate never happened, and from the stated position of the Bola Tinubu’s campaign, Nigerians may never have the opportunity to scrutinise the next likely occupant of Aso Rock.
In 2011, the current President availed himself for the presidential debate, and he lost the election. Sadly, he avoided the debates in 2015 and 2019, but won both elections; and the past seven years have seen Nigeria heading to the precipice in every sector. No Nigerian leader, even in the days of the Military, mismanaged our diversity the extent President Buhari has in the past seven years.

In 2015, Nigerians voted an unrepentant former dictator into office, a tribesman who has given more attention to cows than 200 million Nigerians in the past seven years. Since our forced marriage in 1914, and the horse trading that occurred behind closed doors, between the North and the British before our independence in 1960, there have always been religious and tribal fault lines, but the past crop of leaders even from the North were able to manage it. But President Buhari failed woefully in this regard. His body language and policies in the past seven years have transformed hitherto fault lines to gaping tribal and religious chasms that are now threatening to swallow up the country. In this electoral cycle, Nigerians deserve the opportunity to hear the candidates outline their progammmes, and how they intend to manage our economy, security, education, health, foreign policy, but most importantly, how they intend to manage our diversity.

In the US, political parties organise series of televised presidential debates bordering on key issues like the economy and foreign policy before party primaries. These series of debates go a long way to inform the American voter, especially voters who are unaffiliated to either the Democratic party, or the Republican Party such that, by the time the main debates come around voters are fully primed on what to look out for. The case is different in Nigeria even in 2022, where neither the APC, PDP, LP, NNPP, or any other party for that matter had debates before their various presidential primaries. Essentially, it means that we do not know these candidates the way we ought to. You may recall that during one of the APC’s presidential campaigns in 2015, candidate Muhammadu Buhari was quoted as saying that he was going to make $1 equal to N1, but today, that promise is considered a slip of tongue, or political misspeak. Therefore, going by this,  almost everything a Nigerian politician says  in the campaign trail is worth nothing. This is the reason why the current set of presidential candidates must be put on the spot in a debate setting to face the scrutiny of Nigerians. To be continued in our next edition.

By: Raphael Pepple