Oil & Energy
General Electric, Arco’s Tax Controversy Continues To Generate Ripples
The controversial tax remittance disputes between General Electric and Arco Group Plc have continued to generate ripples, even as the company awaits final resolution.
Documents made available to our source show that GE, a multinational company operating in Nigeria, had engaged Arco, an indigenous Nigerian oil servicing company, for the supply of local personnel.
But Arco in one of its letters dated June 5, 2018, claimed that GE deducted 10 per cent as withholding tax for the contract between 2006 and 2015, against the five per cent stipulated by Nigerian law.
The company said the applicable tax rate should be five per cent in line with the FIRS Circular No. 2006/02, dated February 2006.
The firm however alleged that GE insisted that the rate is 10 per cent in line with the contract for technical services.
In June 2017, Arco wrote GE demanding compliance based on the position of the Lagos State director of FIRS, with claims that the tax filings of both companies fall within Lagos jurisdiction and that the office is competent to give official interpretation of any circular issued by the FIRS.
But in its response, GE directed the firm to write to the Abuja office of the FIRS.
According to Fasilat Ransome-Kuti, who replied on behalf of GE, only such clarification could give the firm comfort’.
“We will not take action on any letter from any other tax office,” she added.
On July 11, 2017, Arco wrote the FIRS seeking clarification on the controversial remittance.
“Our interpretation of the contract of supply is that the applicable WHT rate should be 5% in line with the Federal Inland Revenue Service Circular No. 2006/02 dated February, 2006,” said the firm in the letter signed by Nejoh John.
“However, section 3.5 of the circular (Lines 8-11) referred to what should be classified as technical services states: “…the use of industrial machinery/equipment to provide a service does not render it to be technical because industry position requires that only arrangements that involve a transfer of technology, should be classified as technical,” wrote Arco in a letter seeking clarification from the Federal Inland Revenue Service, FIRS.
The firm also argued that other IOCs it worked for in the past applied WHT rate of five per cent on services rendered to them by Arco.
The FIRS in its response dated November 2, 2017, said the only part of the contract where 10 per cent tax applies is office rent which is to be deducted by Arco and remitted to the FIRS.
GE in its response letter dated January 18, 2018, seen by PREMIUM TIMES, said it would engage its consultant, Price Waterhouse Coopers (PwC), to confirm the technical basis of the conclusion and advise it as appropriate.
Arco in its response, said there was no basis for GE’s attempt to clarify FIRS’ clarification and thus demanded immediate payment of its outstanding invoices underpayments.
“What we are requesting now, is the refund of 50% of total WHT deducted from Arco’s invoices from the period 2006 to 2015 as earlier communicated to you in our letter dated November 6, 2017, following the FIRS’ clarification as follows,” wrote Ben Omotomiye, Group Head Finance and Admin, Arco.
“1. €56,577.61 (Fifty-six thousand, five hundred and seventy-seven euros, sixty-one cents).
“2. $2,923,642.36 (Two million, nine hundred and twenty-three thousand, six hundred and forty-two dollars and thirty-six cents).
“3. N360,482,041.19 (Three hundred and sixty million, four hundred and eighty-two thousand, forty-one naira and nineteen kobo).”
Beginning from the second week of July, several weeks-long efforts by PREMIUM TIMES to get GE’s side of the story proved abortive.
In the last week of July, a spokesperson of the company, Obagbemi Olusegun of BHGE Communications Sub-Saharan Africa, promised to reply our reporter’s email but failed to do so after numerous reminders.
PREMIUM TIMES’ reporter later visited the head office of GE in Victoria Island but was prevented from speaking with officials of the IOC.
Similarly, the FIRS declined to speak on the case as several emails sent to the agency were not replied.
The Guardian later reported that the tax authority has said it will refund the N360 million and $2 million excess withholding tax (WHT) deducted from Arco through its business dealings with General Electric (GE).
The paper said the details were contained in a letter it obtained, dated July 26, 2018, and directed to PricewaterhouseCoopers (PwC) Limited, (tax advisers to GE) with reference number FIRS/TPAD/GEN/272/V.IX/.
“In respect of the treatment of excess WHT deducted from Arco and remitted to FIRS, Arco has either of the following two options: To formally apply to FIRS for the refund of the excess WHT deducted so long as there is evidence of remittance to the FIRS account; or to use same to offset its future tax liabilities,” the FIRS letter reportedly read.
Oil & Energy
Global Power Grid Expansion Surges 50% to Record High
Utilities built a total of over 21,000 km of new transmission lines last year, the International Renewable Energy Agency reported this week at COP31, citing data from a group called the Utilities for Net Zero Alliance. This is 50% more than the new transmission lines installed during the previous year, IRENA noted in its report.
“Power grids will make or break not only the energy transition but also the world’s ambition to raise global electrification to 35% by 2035, as championed by the Turkish COP31 Presidency,” said the director-general of IRENA, Francesco La Camera. “IRENA’s analysis shows that global grid investment must more than double, reaching a cumulative USD 10 trillion by 2035,” he added, noting that ambition would not be enough and that “We must move from targets to implementation, from individual projects to system-wide transformation, and from commitments to delivery at scale.”
Transmission line capacity has become one of the biggest obstacles in the path of the energy transition. Due to their weather-dependent, variable output nature, wind and solar installations generate electricity intermittently. Because the best locations for such installations are often far from electricity demand centers, having to waste output in times of low demand is a frequent occurrence with both. Called curtailment, wind and solar electricity waste increases costs for the alternative energy sources.
The solution, net-zero proponents such as the International Energy Agency believe, is to expand the grid by building new transmission lines connecting wind and solar installations with demand centers. Back in 2023, the IEA said utilities needed to add or replace some 50 million km of transmission lines by 2040 if Paris Agreement signatories were to meet their commitments.
Forecasting how many millions of kilometers of cable need to be built or replaced, however, is one thing, while paying for it is quite another. Last year, the European Commission estimated that the European Union alone needs to cough up between $2 trillion and $2.3 trillion on grid upgrades by 2050 to achieve the Commission’s climate goals. For context, EU investment in the grid in 2024 stood at $90.5 billion. This would need to rise to over $100 billion annually, according to energy think tank Bruegel.
$100 billion in grid buildout investment is no small potatoes, yet some believe this investment would be inevitable as energy security takes priority over climate change concerns. Wood Mackenzie said this week that countries that prioritize energy security over emission-reduction plans could achieve lower emissions through faster electrification, replacing hydrocarbon import dependence.
“The energy transition has arrived at a genuine crossroads,” Prakash Sharma, Wood Mackenzie’s head of scenarios and technologies, said. “The world is no longer moving in one direction. Nations are making fundamentally different choices about how to power their economies, and those choices are producing outcomes that confound conventional wisdom.”
Energy security has indeed come to the fore since February, with emission reduction taking the back seat as governments struggle to keep energy relatively affordable without emptying state coffers and slipping into a recession. This has proven hard for many that depend on imports of oil and gas, with the effects of this dependence especially obvious in most of Asia and the European Union.
Reducing this dependence on imports has become an obvious path for many of these governments, as much as it is possible. And the most obvious way of reducing this dependence has been electrification, wherever possible. According to Wood Mackenzie, the impact of the war in Iran on energy prices would drive a shift to electrification, a wind and solar buildout, and nuclear generation expansion to produce more energy locally. This, in turn, would inevitably lead to lower emissions, even though, ironically, these lower emissions are not the priority.
COP31 host Turkey has proposed that participants commit to electrification, aiming for electricity to account for 35% of final energy. That would be up from some 20% today, with most of the world’s final energy still coming from hydrocarbons despite the net-zero rush from the last ten years. What is interesting, however, is that the proposal does not include a stipulation for reducing the use of hydrocarbons. Based on Wood Mackenzie’s scenario for inadvertent emission reduction, the lower use of hydrocarbons would happen organically rather than by means of government regulation enforcement.
Such developments would be an interesting departure from what has become the standard modus operandi of pro-transition governments: regulation, emission-cutting mandates, and penalties for using hydrocarbons, such as credit offsets. Instead, the energy ramifications of geopolitical events could lead to what one could describe as an organic shift away from imported hydrocarbons, while countries with their own mineral resources exploit those more fully. Whether such an organic shift would indeed reduce the consumption of oil, gas, and coal, however, remains to be seen.
By: Irina Slav
Oil & Energy
Oil Theft: CSO Urges Niger Delta Communities to Support Military Crackdown
Oil & Energy
N639bn Unpaid Gas Debt Threatens Nigeria’s Electricity Supply
-
Business4 days ago
BSG Partiner American Coy To Invest $100m In Gas Processing
-
Oil & Energy4 days agoFG To Double Oil, Gas Reserves, Moves To Intensified fresh Exploration
-
Business4 days ago
Seme Customs Intercepts Live Pacific Ridley Sea Turtle
-
Sports4 days ago
Fernandes Turns Down Man Utd Offer
-
Business4 days ago
159m small businesses registered on database in three years – SMEDAN boss
-
Sports4 days ago
Rivers To Host National Table Tennis Championship
-
Maritime4 days ago
Nimasa,China MSA Sign Bilateral Maritime Agreement
-
Sports4 days agoKenyans Win PH International Marathon, Cart Home $10,000
