Oil & Energy
Why The Energy Sector Is Avoiding Full Emissions Disclosure
The tracking and disclosure of carbon dioxide emissions is at the heart of the energy transition as the first step towards reducing these same emissions. Yet for all the regulatory and activist effort to pressure businesses into full emissions disclosure, it has been tricky, because companies don’t want full emissions disclosure.
A recent study from ESG data provider Clarity AI has revealed that only a tenth of energy companies disclose emissions generated from oil and gas projects in which they participate as investors rather than operators.
The study used data from emission tracker Climate TRACE to show that the great majority of the 20 largest oil and gas companies in the world did not report so-called investment Scope 3 emissions, suggesting this could be problematic for investors.
Scope 3 emissions are the bane of companies’ existence in the current regulatory environment that has prioritized carbon dioxide emissions almost above all else. The pressure to track and report all scopes of emissions is enormous but it is particularly significant in Scope 3: the indirect emissions a company gets on its “bill” from working with suppliers and selling products to clients.
Now, per that Clarity AI study, it emerges that Scope 3 emissions are also the ones generated from projects where companies are only an investor—and they, too, need to be tracked and reported. The idea appears to be that no single molecule of CO2 should go unreported in order to arrest changes in the Earth’s climate.
For obvious reasons, oil and gas companies have been an especially big focus of Scope 3 emission disclosure and reduction efforts due to the nature of their activity, which abounds with all sorts of emissions. For equally obvious reasons, this focus has not made the industry happy, with the general argument being that responsibility for the emissions generated from the use of hydrocarbon products lies with everyone who uses them rather than the ones who produce them.
The reason that oil and gas companies do not want to report their Scope 3 emissions is pretty much the same as the reason for all other companies to be reluctant to do that — the massive amount of resources that would need to go into tracking all indirect emissions a company’s activities produce.
Tracking Scope 3 would involve tracking absolutely every step of the way that a product — or a service — passes from inception to market and that is one quite long way.
The argument of transition advocates is that investors are interested in this sort of information because it helps them make better informed decisions as they increasingly bet on a transition economy. Failing to report Scope 3 emissions, the argument goes, essentially means misleading investors.
Not everyone agrees that reporting all CO2 emissions to the last molecule is all that important, however. “Companies don’t have the incentive to report everything, … just because they don’t have the means to, or haven’t been able to measure it,” said Patricia Pina, the head of Clarity AI’s product research and innovation, told Inside Climate News.
Indeed, some transition advocates attach zero importance to detailed emission reporting, instead prioritizing direct and “decisive” decarbonization.
Commenting on the study to Inside Climate News, the head of the Erasmus platform for sustainable value creation at Ereasmus University in Rotterdam said that while it is understandable why oil and gas companies might not be enthusiastic about Scope 3 reporting, “we don’t really need them to do that. We need them to transition decisively to net zero and to invest massively in renewable energy”.
It appears, then, that not everyone in the pro-decarbonization camp feels equally strongly bout indirect emissions, specifically from investments. Yet the issue could yet become problematic for energy companies if enough pro-transition investors take it to heart as they did all other Scope 3 emissions.
On the flip side, climate-related shareholder resolutions have seen a decline in shareholder support over the past couple of years, which might suggest that investor interest in emissions, direct or indirect, is waning, replaced by things like returns.
This waning interest has coincided with companies beginning to revise their climate commitments, including emission reporting.
The latter trend was detected by the Energy Institute in its latest Statistical Review of World Energy, which revealed that the commitments companies made years ago were unrealistically ambitious.
In a sense, the corporate world woke up to the reality that lightning fast decarbonization is physically impossible and likely financial undesirable.
“Everyone got swept up in a wave of enthusiasm”, the head of sustainable investing research at one Dutch asset manager told the FT last month. “The reality is not so easy”.
Indeed, it appears that enthusiasm for everything from wind and solar to Scope 3 emissions reporting is weakening, to be replaced by a more level-headed approach to energy and corporate management.
By: Irina Slav
Oil & Energy
Global Power Grid Expansion Surges 50% to Record High
Utilities built a total of over 21,000 km of new transmission lines last year, the International Renewable Energy Agency reported this week at COP31, citing data from a group called the Utilities for Net Zero Alliance. This is 50% more than the new transmission lines installed during the previous year, IRENA noted in its report.
“Power grids will make or break not only the energy transition but also the world’s ambition to raise global electrification to 35% by 2035, as championed by the Turkish COP31 Presidency,” said the director-general of IRENA, Francesco La Camera. “IRENA’s analysis shows that global grid investment must more than double, reaching a cumulative USD 10 trillion by 2035,” he added, noting that ambition would not be enough and that “We must move from targets to implementation, from individual projects to system-wide transformation, and from commitments to delivery at scale.”
Transmission line capacity has become one of the biggest obstacles in the path of the energy transition. Due to their weather-dependent, variable output nature, wind and solar installations generate electricity intermittently. Because the best locations for such installations are often far from electricity demand centers, having to waste output in times of low demand is a frequent occurrence with both. Called curtailment, wind and solar electricity waste increases costs for the alternative energy sources.
The solution, net-zero proponents such as the International Energy Agency believe, is to expand the grid by building new transmission lines connecting wind and solar installations with demand centers. Back in 2023, the IEA said utilities needed to add or replace some 50 million km of transmission lines by 2040 if Paris Agreement signatories were to meet their commitments.
Forecasting how many millions of kilometers of cable need to be built or replaced, however, is one thing, while paying for it is quite another. Last year, the European Commission estimated that the European Union alone needs to cough up between $2 trillion and $2.3 trillion on grid upgrades by 2050 to achieve the Commission’s climate goals. For context, EU investment in the grid in 2024 stood at $90.5 billion. This would need to rise to over $100 billion annually, according to energy think tank Bruegel.
$100 billion in grid buildout investment is no small potatoes, yet some believe this investment would be inevitable as energy security takes priority over climate change concerns. Wood Mackenzie said this week that countries that prioritize energy security over emission-reduction plans could achieve lower emissions through faster electrification, replacing hydrocarbon import dependence.
“The energy transition has arrived at a genuine crossroads,” Prakash Sharma, Wood Mackenzie’s head of scenarios and technologies, said. “The world is no longer moving in one direction. Nations are making fundamentally different choices about how to power their economies, and those choices are producing outcomes that confound conventional wisdom.”
Energy security has indeed come to the fore since February, with emission reduction taking the back seat as governments struggle to keep energy relatively affordable without emptying state coffers and slipping into a recession. This has proven hard for many that depend on imports of oil and gas, with the effects of this dependence especially obvious in most of Asia and the European Union.
Reducing this dependence on imports has become an obvious path for many of these governments, as much as it is possible. And the most obvious way of reducing this dependence has been electrification, wherever possible. According to Wood Mackenzie, the impact of the war in Iran on energy prices would drive a shift to electrification, a wind and solar buildout, and nuclear generation expansion to produce more energy locally. This, in turn, would inevitably lead to lower emissions, even though, ironically, these lower emissions are not the priority.
COP31 host Turkey has proposed that participants commit to electrification, aiming for electricity to account for 35% of final energy. That would be up from some 20% today, with most of the world’s final energy still coming from hydrocarbons despite the net-zero rush from the last ten years. What is interesting, however, is that the proposal does not include a stipulation for reducing the use of hydrocarbons. Based on Wood Mackenzie’s scenario for inadvertent emission reduction, the lower use of hydrocarbons would happen organically rather than by means of government regulation enforcement.
Such developments would be an interesting departure from what has become the standard modus operandi of pro-transition governments: regulation, emission-cutting mandates, and penalties for using hydrocarbons, such as credit offsets. Instead, the energy ramifications of geopolitical events could lead to what one could describe as an organic shift away from imported hydrocarbons, while countries with their own mineral resources exploit those more fully. Whether such an organic shift would indeed reduce the consumption of oil, gas, and coal, however, remains to be seen.
By: Irina Slav
Oil & Energy
Oil Theft: CSO Urges Niger Delta Communities to Support Military Crackdown
Oil & Energy
N639bn Unpaid Gas Debt Threatens Nigeria’s Electricity Supply
-
Business4 days ago
BSG Partiner American Coy To Invest $100m In Gas Processing
-
Oil & Energy4 days agoFG To Double Oil, Gas Reserves, Moves To Intensified fresh Exploration
-
Business4 days ago
Seme Customs Intercepts Live Pacific Ridley Sea Turtle
-
Sports4 days ago
Fernandes Turns Down Man Utd Offer
-
Business4 days ago
159m small businesses registered on database in three years – SMEDAN boss
-
Sports4 days ago
Rivers To Host National Table Tennis Championship
-
Maritime4 days ago
Nimasa,China MSA Sign Bilateral Maritime Agreement
-
Sports4 days agoKenyans Win PH International Marathon, Cart Home $10,000
