Opinion
When A Noble Idea Fails
In the pre-election year of 2018, former governor of Plateau State, His Excellency, Simon Lalong, listed a very promising package among projects to be commissioned by former President Muhammadu Buhari, who was on State visit – the roll-out of 400 tractors to be distributed to farmers as a boost to agriculture in the state. It was an event publicised with so much fanfare and applauded by farmers who anticipated reliefs that would revolutionise their labourious methods of farming to transit from manual farming into mechanisation, while at the same time achieve greater outputs and profits. Commissioned precisely on March 8, 2018, the tractorisation initiative was aimed at enabling farmers own tractors for farming in Plateau State.
As at then the state’s Agricultural Services training centre and Marketing Ltd (ASTC & M Ltd) had only 300 tractors which it had managed and hired out to farmers since its establishment, but that number was not enough given the enormous demand. Plateau state, with its expanse of fertile lands, geographic location and topography, is one of Nigeria’s food baskets, but massive production is hampered by manual farming. It was therefore cheery news when it filtered out that farmers would be assisted to own tractors to ease their labour, while achieving greater production.
According to sources, Hakar Engineering Nigeria Limited had in 2016 proposed a tripartite, Public, Private Partnership initiative involving themselves, the plateau state Government and the State farmers through Plateau State All-Farmers Multi-Purpose Co-operative Limited, with regard to a co-funding arrangement that would enable farmers in the state acquire tractors. The state and local governments were to subsidise the tractors with 30 per cer and 10 per cent payments respectively, while participating farmers were to pay the remaining 60 per cent. With an initial down payment of 10 per cent, a farmer was to take delivery of a tractor, while payment of the 50 per cent balance would be spread over a three-year period as farmers make proceeds from improved agro outputs. The scheme was also packaged with trainings for would-be tractor operators, while services and repair workshops were to be established across the three geo-political zones of the state.
However, on the day of commissioning, only 40 out of the publicised 400 tractors were displayed. Mr Lalong reportedly explained that government house premises, venue for the commissioning exercise, was too small to contain all 400 tractors, hence the reason for displaying only 40, implying that all 400 tractors had already been supplied. Mr Lalong went further to claim that the state government procured the 400 tractors for farmers at the cost of N5.6 billion, at N14 million per set. Regrettably, with very few of the participating farmers having received tractors years after commissioning of the scheme, controversy now rages as to the whereabouts of the 400 tractors, as well as the actual financial stake of Plateau State Government. This is as the N5.6 billion claimed to have been the cost by Mr Lalong far out-weighs the state government’s 30 per cent counterpart funding of N1.68 billion, if the whole 400 tractors were supplied.
Media investigations reveal that while the number of tractors actually supplied was less than 100 in the first and only batch made, data from Plateau state shows that 400 tractors and farm implements were procured in 2019 at a total cost of N5.6 billion. But for a project that was to involve the state Ministry of Agriculture and State Bureau of Public Procurement, both organisations according to PREMIUM TIMES have denied involvement in, or knowledgement of, any such transactions. Also, farmers complain of getting an unfamiliar brand that is alien to their experience, as against the promised Massey Ferguson brand that has spare parts and service technicians locally available, and also complain of incomplete accessories and no accompanying spare parts as promised, while service centres were not made available. This sad experience in Plateau state mirrows the wider national scenerios where the wrong implementation of noble ideas kills bigger dreams and denies the nation of intended benefits.
It is a typical example of cases in which public officials sometimes alter the design contents of Memorandum of Understandings (MoUs) signed for mutual benefits. According to PREMIUM TIMES, an official of Hakar Engineering Nigeria Limited confided anonymously that what the company proposed to Plateau State Government in 2016 was a partnership MoU that was intended to help farming businesses in the state while promoting government’s agricultural programmes, hence did not go through the bureau of public procurement, but it was surprising to see it presented to the public in 2018 as a N5.6 billion contract with the state government. To whom then was N5.6 billion paid or was Mr Lalong carried away by a zeal to impress the public being that 2018 was pre-election year, or was it a case of avarice? The claim by the state’s ministry of agriculture that they are investigating the whole affair adds more complexity and suspicion to the entire saga.
No matter how politically connected the proponents of the partnership were the ministry of agriculture, who should own such a scheme, should have been the originating department where the proposal was presented, with MoU drafted on behalf of the state government, and should have been the government’s department to administer the processes, take delivery of tractors, keep custody, make allocations to farmers and detail any feed-backs, and not the Plateau State Government House. On the other hand, if Hakar Engineering Nigeria Limited truly had the requisite financial capacity, technical support and managerial skills to implement such tractorisation programme for farmers, they should have executed the partnership directly with farmers and handle the execution processes as a business entity without seeking political connections.
Unfortunately, while left with broken tractors with no available spare parts and experienced technicians, farmers trapped in the failed scheme now live in regrets for believing and investing in a public programme. Yes, while those farmers bemourn their failed investments and faith in a scheme, it is the wider Nigerian populace that take the implicit heat as food scarcities continue to push many into poverty and hunger. 400 tractors rightly introduced in 2018 into the hard-working hands of astute farmers in Plateau state could have been a game changer for Nigeria, by encouraging the partners to replicate such across other states, long before the COVID 19 era, long before Russia’s escapades in Ukraine and Hammas’attack on Isreal, all three major factors that disrupted the international supply chains Nigeria had relied upon out of sheer complacency.
By: Joseph Nwankwo
Opinion
Flamingos’ Triumph, Nigeria’s Responsibility
Quote: “The Flamingos have conquered the world; Nigeria must now rise to its responsibility of nurturing the next generation of champions.”
Sometimes, sporting victories
More significantly, they
Umejiaku deserves special
Umejiaku received the award
Nigeria has now broken into
For too long, young girls in
But beyond the reward, this
As Nigerians celebrate this
By; Calista Ezeaku
Opinion
Making Public Toilets Truly Convenient
Opinion
Ken Saro-Wiwa’s Unfinished Struggle (I)
On November 10, 1995, the Nigerian military government of General Sani Abacha executed Ken Saro-Wiwa and eight other Ogoni leaders after a deeply controversial trial. Their deaths marked one of the darkest chapters in Nigeria’s history. At a time when fear silenced citizens and sycophancy flourished around military power, Saro-Wiwa chose to confront tyranny. Many Nigerians retreated into silence, while others praised the regime to secure favour. He knew the risks, yet refused to abandon a people whose land had been devastated by oil exploration and whose lives remained trapped in poverty. His courage arose from the conviction that public responsibility sometimes demands resistance to authority. Saro-Wiwa understood that speaking against a military government could lead to imprisonment or death.
Nonetheless, he believed the suffering of the Ogoni people demanded a courageous response. While oil was extracted from their land, they were left with polluted rivers, damaged farmland, declining livelihoods and an environment hostile to human survival. Fishing grounds and sources of livelihood were threatened, while the people struggled to secure basic amenities. The wealth beneath their soil brought neither adequate development nor a fair share of national resources. For him, silence in the face of injustice would have amounted to complicity. Through the Movement for the Survival of the Ogoni People (MOSOP), he organised a peaceful campaign that took the Ogoni question to the international community. MOSOP gave ordinary people an organised platform through which to express their grievances and insist on recognition.
The Ogoni Bill of Rights, presented to the Federal Government in 1990, demanded political autonomy, economic justice, environmental protection and control over the people’s resources. The campaign exposed the human and ecological costs of oil operations, particularly those associated with Shell, and challenged the apparent alliance between corporate interests and an unresponsive State. The Ogoni struggle became a defining expression of minority rights and environmental justice in Nigeria and Africa. Saro-Wiwa’s writings and mobilisation drew attention to communities treated as expendable because of their limited population and political influence. He argued that numerical strength should never determine a people’s value or rights.
A minority community does not become less deserving of justice because it cannot command electoral numbers or political power. In Nigeria, every ethnic group deserves dignity, protection and a fair opportunity to benefit from the commonwealth. Rather than respond to peaceful agitation with dialogue, the Abacha regime resorted to repression. Ogoni leaders were harassed, detained and killed; others fled into exile. The crisis intensified after four Ogoni chiefs were killed in May 1994. Saro-Wiwa and other MOSOP leaders were arrested, tried by a special tribunal and executed despite international appeals for clemency and serious concerns about the trial’s fairness. The executions drew worldwide condemnation and intensified scrutiny of Nigeria’s human-rights record and oil companies in the Niger Delta.
They demonstrated the danger of using State institutions to suppress peaceful demands. The proceedings remain a reminder of the need for judicial independence and due process. Saro-Wiwa’s courage rested on the conviction that justice must be pursued despite the cost. His method combined non-violent resistance, public education and grassroots organisation. His struggle recalled the civil-rights campaign of Martin Luther King Jr. and the power of peaceful mobilisation against injustice. Saro-Wiwa linked environmental degradation to political exclusion, economic exploitation and the denial of democratic rights. Oil-producing communities, he insisted, should not remain zones from which wealth is removed to develop other parts of the country.
Their people must benefit through roads, schools, healthcare, jobs and clean water. Resource extraction carries a duty to protect host communities. His argument extended to the structure of the Nigerian federation. He challenged a revenue-allocation system that made oil-producing communities bear the environmental and social costs of extraction without commensurate benefits. Like advocates of fiscal federalism, he believed resources should be managed and shared equitably. He envisaged a society in which no community would be disadvantaged by its size, ethnicity, political affiliation, culture or religion. His vision was a country bound together by justice and equal citizenship. Saro-Wiwa was also a gifted writer, dramatist and public intellectual.
Through books, essays, plays and television, he documented Nigerian society’s contradictions and challenged abuses of power. His popular television series, Basi and Company, demonstrated his creative range, while his leadership of the Association of Nigerian Authors encouraged writers to engage national questions. He believed literature should not be detached from society’s struggles. His pen exposed environmental injustice, political repression and the dangers of silencing courageous voices. He used storytelling, satire and drama to shape public consciousness and expose social contradictions. His literary achievements gave his activism wider reach and made the Ogoni experience part of national conversation. His commitment to the Ogoni people extended beyond the oil question.
During the Civil War, he worked to protect his vulnerable community. He urged younger generations to reject subservience and complacency and pursue change through lawful, peaceful means. Citizens, he believed, must not surrender their responsibility to challenge wrong doing. An injury to one community threatens the rights and security of all. The return to democratic government in 1999 and the establishment of the Niger Delta Development Commission, the Ministry of Niger Delta Affairs and the Hydrocarbon Pollution Remediation Project (HYPREP) are among developments that have kept the region’s demands in public view. Saro-Wiwa did not create these institutions, but his movement helped expose the urgency of intervention and sustain pressure for redress.
His death made it harder to ignore the Niger Delta’s environmental and political grievances. Yet, interventionist institutions do not prove that the original demands have been met. Their effectiveness depends on competent leadership, transparent spending, measurable outcomes and community participation. Yet, thirty-one years after his execution, the central concerns of the Ogoni struggle remain unresolved. The HYPREP-led clean-up has offered hope, but many residents await meaningful improvements. Questions persist about the programme’s pace, quality and transparency, and whether its benefits reach ordinary people. A clean-up should be judged not by ceremonies or contracts, but by restored land and waterways, safe drinking water, improved livelihoods and better public health.
It must include long-term monitoring to ensure treated sites remain safe. Residents deserve information about contamination, remediation methods and completion timelines. Reports that water projects in Gwara and Ebubu Communities, in Khana and Eleme Local Government Areas respectively, failed weeks after commissioning have raised further concerns. If confirmed, the failures would indicate weaknesses in supervision, procurement and quality control.
To be continued in our next edition.
Taneh Beemene
-
News5 days ago
RSG Reaffirms Commitment To STEM Education, Technological Advancement
-
Business5 days ago
‘NUJ, NPA’s Partnership Would Boost Port Producrivity, Economic Growth’
-
News5 days agoIGP Warns Police Officers Against Partisanship …Directs Regular Engagement With Journalists
-
Oil & Energy2 days agoFG To Double Oil, Gas Reserves, Moves To Intensified fresh Exploration
-
Business2 days ago
BSG Partiner American Coy To Invest $100m In Gas Processing
-
Business2 days ago
Seme Customs Intercepts Live Pacific Ridley Sea Turtle
-
Business5 days ago
Fire Threat Interrupts Asaba Air Peace Flight
-
News5 days agoCustoms To Deploy AI, Scanners Against Snuggling
