Opinion
VAT Increase: How Fair?
On Tuesday, March 19, 2019, the then Minister for Budget and National Planning, Senator Udoma Udo Udoma, and the Executive Chairman of the Federal Inland Revenue Service (FIRS), Babatunde Fowler, hinted the National Assembly that the Value Added Tax (VAT) rate is likely to go up.
Their statement was later corroborated in July, as the Chairman, Revenue Mobilisation Allocation and Fiscal Commission (RMFAC), Engr. Elias Mbam, added his voice to the demand for an increment in VAT from 5 per cent to about 7.5 per cent to shore up Nigeria’s revenue base which he said is heavily reliant on oil earnings.
The message became clearer on September 11, when the the current Minister of Finance, Budget and National Planning, Zainab Ahmed, spoke on the proposed plan to increse VAT at the end of the Federal Executive Council meeting. She said: “We also reported to council and council has agreed that we start the process towards the increase of the VAT rate. We are proposing and council has agreed to increase the VAT rate from five percent to 7.2 percent”.
For the trio; Udoma, Fowler and Zainab, an increase in VAT is not just needed to shore up Nigeria’s revenue base as posited by Engr Mbam, it is necessary to enable government fund the new minimum wage of N30,000 per month approved by the National Assembly.
While the Senate Committee on Finance awaits the details on reasons for the proposed increase by the finance minister and chairman, FIRS, the move had generated mixed reactions among the public on its possible effects on living standards and the economy.
Ordinarily, increasing VAT by the government of the day shouldn’t warant the magnitude of reaction as witnessed in this case. After all, such could still serve as a veritable means of meeting the expansive fiscal expenditure needs of the federal government. Besides, the World Bank recently noted that fiscal deficits in Nigeria will likely widen further due to increased pre-election spending and sustained revenue shortfalls.
But while the need for government to bridge its revenue gap remains incontestable, and while it also reserves the right to adopt any legitimate measure in its revenue generation drive, VAT increment inclusive, the writer is rather worried about the time the VAT increase measure is deemed apt for such purpose.
If Udoma, Fowler, and Zainab’s reason for the planned increment is anything to go by, then there is need for more innovative approaches to scaling up the government’s revenue capacities so as to meet its growing funding commitments, especially, against the background of increasingly financing its fiscal deficit from borrowings.
Let us not forget that there are expectations that the increase in minimum wage could possibly be eroded by price increases of key household items, offsetting the expected improvement in purchasing power. And for the Nigerian industrial climate, you can guess what hope this portends for foreign investments and the faith of the Small and Medium Enterprises (SMEs).
I hope the government’s enamoured pursuit of increasing revenue should not be to the detriment of the wellbeing of its own citizens as the choice of VAT increase upon the prevailing economic realities could be interpreted to be.
CSL Stockbrokers confirmed the above fears when it declared that “financing the increment in the wage burden through tax increment would force companies to raise prices significantly, ultimately placing the incidence of the tax increment on the consumers. It is, therefore, considered a bad timing and inconsistent with current economic reality”.
VAT, as we know, is basically imposed on consumption. Apart from the already diminished scale of consumption in the Nigerian economy which invariably may affect the collection performance of VAT, a simple economic analysis would attest that any increase in VAT at this time, would disproportionately affect poor people. But even beyond that argument, the biggest challenge is that any increase in indirect taxes affects the prices of goods and services.
This, analysts argued, could in turn affect the country’s inflation rate. With an inflation rate of over 11 per cent, the outcome of the proposed VAT increase is very critical given that the Central Bank of Nigeria is keen to contain inflationary pressures in the economy and bring inflation back to a single digit within a target range of 6-9 percent. It is thus expected that the rise in VAT would likely lead to a rise in inflation.
Moreso, in a clime like ours where the poverty level of the general populace has eroded their economic power, VAT increase may further worsen the living conditions of consumers whose real income has been stifled over the years. According to a recent report, “one striking feature in the performance of consumer goods companies over the past 18 months, is the consistent decline in reported revenue, suggesting that consumer demand remains weak.”
Well-meaning Nigerians have said “the consequence of this hike on the lives of Nigerians that are already suffering horrendous deprivations is dire and so, capable of exacerbating the poverty that has ravaged the people” .
The writer is of the view that at a time like this, when Nigerian workers expect an upward review in their monthly remuneration, in order to be economically repositioned, a planned corresponding increase in the prices of consumer goods by the government does not portray the government as one with the intention of making positive impacts on the lives of its citizens.
By this proposal, I am afraid the government risks being interpreted as one that does not realise the depth of misery that pervades our nation and may have probably completely detached itself from the people it ought to succour; a reason, I guess, the organised labour described this planned increase as anti-people and anti-development.
The reality is that any increase in VAT will be counter-intuitive to the goals of reducing poverty and inequality given the existing high economic disparity in the country.
In fairness to all, the proposed increase in VAT, by the federal government will not only weaken the citizens’ purchasing power, but would also worsen the poverty level in the country.
I, therefore, see this obvious call on the manufacturers and stake holders in the chain of distribution to hike the cost of their merchandise to the detriment of the suffering masses, as a concept billed for still birth.
Sylvia ThankGod-Amadi
Opinion
Nigeria’s Burden Of Economic Hardship
There is growing need for urgent and sustained attention to the severe economic hardship confronting millions of Nigerians. Across the country, the ordinary citizen is increasingly finding it difficult to cope with the demands of daily living. For many households, survival has become a struggle, as the rising cost of essential goods and services continues to erode incomes and diminish the purchasing power of families. What was once considered a manageable cost of living has become an overwhelming burden for workers, traders, artisans, students and other vulnerable members of society. One of the most visible manifestations of this hardship is the astronomical increase in food prices. Staple commodities such as rice, garri, beans, yam, cooking oil and other basic necessities have become increasingly unaffordable.
Families that once managed to provide three meals daily are now compelled to reduce their food consumption, compromise on nutritional quality or skip meals altogether. The situation is particularly troubling for low-income earners whose salaries have remained largely inadequate to meet the escalating cost of household needs. Food is not a luxury; it is a basic human necessity. Therefore, when a significant proportion of the population struggles to afford what should ordinarily be within reach, it raises serious questions about the effectiveness of economic policies and the government’s commitment to citizens’ welfare. Transportation has equally become a major source of financial pressure. Following the removal of fuel subsidy, petrol prices increased considerably, triggering corresponding increases in transport fares and the cost of moving goods and services.
Workers now spend a substantial portion of their monthly earnings commuting to and from their workplaces. Traders and small-scale entrepreneurs face higher operational costs as transporting merchandise from markets to their shops becomes increasingly expensive. The consequences extend to the education sector. Some school children are compelled to trek considerable distances because their parents cannot afford daily transportation fares. This situation not only exposes children to physical exhaustion and possible security risks but also threatens their punctuality, concentration and overall educational experience. No child should have to choose between attending school and the financial limitations of the family. Unemployment further compounds the economic crisis.
Thousands of graduates leave tertiary institutions every year with hopes of securing meaningful employment, only to encounter a labour market with limited opportunities. Many remain unemployed for years, while others accept jobs that offer little financial security. The situation is particularly discouraging for young people who have invested time, resources and energy in acquiring education but cannot translate their qualifications into productive livelihoods.Small businesses and artisans are also bearing the consequences of the harsh economic environment. The high cost of raw materials, electricity, transportation and other operational expenses has forced many entrepreneurs to reduce their activities or shut down completely. Businesses that should ordinarily provide employment and stimulate economic growth are instead struggling to remain afloat.
This development creates a damaging cycle in which business closures increase unemployment, reduce household incomes and further weaken consumer spending. The social implications of prolonged economic hardship cannot be ignored. When people are unable to meet basic needs despite working hard, frustration, desperation and hopelessness can take root. Young people who cannot find legitimate means of livelihood may become vulnerable to criminal activities, drug abuse, human trafficking and other social vices. Although poverty does not automatically lead to crime, widespread economic deprivation can create conditions that make social instability more difficult to contain. It is particularly painful that Nigeria, a country endowed with enormous natural resources, fertile agricultural land and an energetic, intellectually capable population, continues to experience such widespread economic distress.
The country’s potential for agricultural productivity, industrial development and employment generation remains enormous. What is required is the political will, institutional efficiency and consistent policy implementation to translate these advantages into improved living conditions. The Federal Government must therefore intensify efforts to address the situation through practical and sustainable interventions. Agriculture deserves particular attention. Farmers should have access to affordable fertilisers, improved seedlings, modern equipment, agricultural financing and adequate security on their farms. Strengthening local food production and distribution will help increase supply, reduce dependence on expensive imports and moderate food prices.
Equally important is the need to create an enabling environment for businesses to thrive. Small and medium-scale enterprises should receive accessible loans, tax relief where appropriate, reliable electricity and other forms of institutional support. Such interventions will encourage entrepreneurship, protect existing jobs and create new employment opportunities, particularly for young Nigerians. Government must also strengthen social protection programmes and ensure that palliatives reach their intended beneficiaries. Assistance should not exist merely in official announcements, policy documents or television broadcasts. It must be transparent, verifiable and accessible to genuinely vulnerable households in both rural communities and urban centres.
Ultimately, economic policies must be evaluated by their impact on the lives of ordinary citizens. Macroeconomic indicators may provide useful information about the direction of the economy, but they cannot replace the lived experiences of families struggling to afford food, pay transport fares and keep their businesses open. Nigerians are not asking for luxury or privileges. They are asking for an economy in which honest work can provide a decent living, businesses can survive, children can attend school without undue hardship and families can afford their basic necessities. The government must treat this expectation as a responsibility, not a favour. The time for urgent, people-centred action is now.
Favour Umunnakwe
Umunnakwe is an intern with The Tide Newspaper.
Opinion
What Opposition Is
In a democracy, political power is never expected to operate without scrutiny. Those entrusted with public authority must be answerable to the people, while those outside government have a legitimate responsibility to question, challenge and offer alternatives to the policies and decisions of those in power. This is the essence of opposition. It is an indispensable feature of democratic governance, providing the counterweight that prevents political authority from becoming absolute. Opposition, therefore, is not simply the existence of political parties outside government. It is an institutional responsibility to provide checks and balances, promote accountability, protect democratic values and offer alternative approaches to governance. Its relevance lies not in the ability to discredit the ruling party but in its capacity to ensure that the government remains responsive to the needs and aspirations of the people.
Since Nigeria’s return to democratic rule in 1999, the country’s political landscape has witnessed changes in leadership, party dominance, defections and shifting political alliances. Through these developments, opposition parties have remained an important part of the democratic process. However, the quality of opposition is as important as its existence. A country may have several political parties, but where they lack clear ideologies, credible leadership and the capacity to interrogate government policies constructively, democratic competition becomes weak. What, then, should opposition do? First, it must hold government accountable. This involves scrutinising public expenditure, questioning questionable decisions, demanding transparency and drawing attention to policies that undermine public welfare. Where government fails to fulfil its promises, opposition parties should demand explanations and insist on corrective measures. This responsibility is particularly important in Nigeria, where citizens continue to contend with economic hardship, insecurity, unemployment and the rising cost of living.
Second, opposition must provide alternatives. Criticism without constructive proposals is insufficient. Political parties seeking to replace an incumbent government must demonstrate that they possess the ideas, competence and leadership capacity to govern differently and better. They must develop policies that address the country’s challenges and communicate practical solutions to the electorate. Opposition should not merely identify problems; it should demonstrate how those problems can be resolved. Third, opposition serves as a safeguard against authoritarian tendencies. Democracy thrives where dissent is tolerated, fundamental rights are protected and institutions operate independently. By questioning the exercise of executive power and defending constitutional provisions, opposition parties help preserve the democratic space. Their role becomes particularly significant when government actions threaten freedom of expression, political participation and the rule of law.
However, opposition is not synonymous with hostility, obstruction or political desperation. It does not mean rejecting every government policy simply because it originates from the ruling party. When government makes decisions that advance the public interest, responsible opposition should acknowledge and support them. Equally, disagreement must be expressed through lawful and democratic channels, not violence, intimidation, misinformation or attempts to destabilise legitimate institutions. The growing conversations around political alliances and opposition cooperation ahead of the 2027 general elections also provide an opportunity to examine the character of opposition in Nigeria. Collaboration among political parties can strengthen democratic competition, particularly where fragmented opposition forces struggle to challenge a dominant ruling party. Nevertheless, alliances must be built on shared principles, coherent programmes and a genuine commitment to national development.
A coalition formed solely to dislodge an incumbent or distribute political offices may offer little assurance of better governance. Opposition parties must also put their own houses in order. They cannot credibly demand transparency and internal democracy from the ruling party while practising imposition, exclusion and intolerance within their organisations. Their leaders must demonstrate integrity, discipline and respect for democratic procedures. Nigerians need alternatives that inspire confidence, not merely familiar politicians changing party platforms in pursuit of personal advantage. The ruling party, on its part, must understand that criticism is not an act of treason. Opposition leaders, civil society organisations, journalists and ordinary citizens must be allowed to express legitimate disagreements without intimidation or harassment. Government must recognise that the right to dissent is constitutionally protected and that the strength of democracy is demonstrated by its ability to accommodate competing opinions.
Ultimately, opposition is about responsibility, not bitterness; accountability, not antagonism; and national interest, not personal ambition. It is an essential democratic institution that keeps government on its toes, widens political choices and ensures that public power remains subject to scrutiny. Nigeria needs an opposition that is courageous enough to challenge wrongdoing, responsible enough to acknowledge good governance and visionary enough to offer credible alternatives. Equally, it needs a government secure enough to welcome scrutiny and humble enough to correct its mistakes. That is what opposition is, and that is what democratic governance requires.
Sylvia ThankGod-Amadi
Opinion
Flamingos’ Triumph, Nigeria’s Responsibility
Quote: “The Flamingos have conquered the world; Nigeria must now rise to its responsibility of nurturing the next generation of champions.”
Sometimes, sporting victories
More significantly, they
Umejiaku deserves special
Umejiaku received the award
Nigeria has now broken into
For too long, young girls in
But beyond the reward, this
As Nigerians celebrate this
By; Calista Ezeaku
-
Business5 days ago
BSG Partiner American Coy To Invest $100m In Gas Processing
-
Oil & Energy5 days agoFG To Double Oil, Gas Reserves, Moves To Intensified fresh Exploration
-
Business5 days ago
Seme Customs Intercepts Live Pacific Ridley Sea Turtle
-
News16 hours ago
Parents Protest Scholarship Scheme Suspension At PAMO Varsity
-
News14 hours agoUS Hails Nigerian Military For Rescuing 125 Kidnap Victims
-
Sports5 days ago
Fernandes Turns Down Man Utd Offer
-
Business5 days ago
159m small businesses registered on database in three years – SMEDAN boss
-
Sports5 days ago
Rivers To Host National Table Tennis Championship
